Tuesday, February 8, 2011

New DOE Data Out

The NJ Department of Education has posted the 2009-2010 School Report Cards, and just about everyone’s covering the release. See here for Star-Ledger , NJ Spotlight, The Record, Asbury Park Press, Courier Post, and Press of Atlantic City. The general consensus is that test scores are uneven and costs are up, though less so in poor urban districts. If you’re a glass-half-full person, then revel in the information that our high school kids improved slightly in language arts and cost per pupil dipped in Newark and other urban districts. If you’re a glass-half-empty person, mourn that middle school scores are down, one out of six high school seniors failed the qualifying math test, and most districts spend more than $15,000 per pupil.

Or maybe you should put down the glass. Both NJ Spotlight and the Star-Ledger suggest that the data is “suspect” in the context of national spending because most states include pricey but non-instructional items like transportation, food services, pension payments, health benefits in publicly-accessible databases, and NJ doesn’t. From the Star-Ledger:
"The data are not completely accurate," said [Education Commissioner Chris] Cerf, who was appointed in December and is awaiting Senate confirmation. "They under-represent and drastically understate the per-pupil cost, and I’m committed to doing a better job on this in the future. These data need to improve."
Example: the DOE Report Card database lists Newark’s average comparative-cost-per-pupil as dropping from $19,058 in 2008-2009 to $13,833 in 2010. But the Newark Business Administrator says that “actual spending was $18,894.”

As long as we’re dealing with educational absurdities, take a look at At Avalon Elementary School, pointed to by the Star-Ledger as the most expensive school district in the state. According to the DOE, there are 77 kids in the grade 1-8 school (maybe there weren’t any kindergarteners last year?), with a high of 13 kids in eighth grade and a low of 5 kids in sixth grade. Comparative cost per pupil is $35,882.

The Star-Ledger quotes chief school administrator David Rauenzahn, who defends the cost because “student achievement in Avalon... is very good and residents support their schools.”

Damn straight they do.

4 comments:

mike said...

hi and hope this finds you well.

Another good overview of current news in our schools.

Wondering: You example of Avalon being the most expensive...

How much state money goes into this community?

The cost per pupil figure is a difficult number to draw conclusions from...

thanks... mike

NJ Left Behind said...

Hi, Mike. Here's the link for Avalon's budget: http://www.state.nj.us/education/finance/fp/ufb/reports/09-0170.html

It actually shows a 2010 enrollment of 64 kids. The total operating budget is $3,285,400. Local tax levy covers most of it: $3,078,694. About $98,000 comes from the State.

mike said...

hi Laura... hope this finds
you well.

Thank you for your quick responce.

So... although Avalon has the highest per pupil cost in the state... around 35,000 dollars per student.... only 98,000 dollars out of a 3.2 million dollar budget comes from the state.

I am guessing that the community of Avalon is willing to pay for their students public school education. Interesting what our wealthier communities are willing to pay for...

So... although the per pupil cost number sounds really high... very little of that cost is a burden to anyone in the state.

These kind of situations exist all around our state.

Wondering if you have come across any data on what percentage of the cost of public school in NJ comes from the state and where NJ stands national on the percentage of money it kicks in to fund public schools in comparison to other states??

My guess is it is low?

Once again... a great blog...thanks for all the work you do in maintaining it....

mike

NJ Left Behind said...

According to Wikipedia, Mike, the average cost of a home in Avalon is $1,567,662. So, yes, I imagine the $35K cost per pupil is pocket change. (Interestingly, though, the DOE lists Avalon's DFG as FG.) You might want to take a look at Bruce Baker's blog, schoolfinance101.wordpress.com. He's done a lot of work on NJ's school funding compared to other states.